Category: Politics

  • BRIAN TOOHEY. The US doesn’t need Asia

    The US doesn’t need to be the dominant power in Asia to maintain its own national security. No amount of wishful thinking can negate this key insight from Hugh White, a leading professor of strategic studies, about the government’s latest foreign policy White Paper. (more…)

  • ROGER SCOTT. Queensland State Election: Winners and Losers

    The last rites were a long time coming but can now be pronounced with confidence. On Monday night, the TJ Ryan Foundation held a post-election function advertised as ‘Who Won and Why’. Even then, over a fortnight after polling day, no-one was absolutely sure, despite Antony Green’s cautious prediction on election night. Counting was painfully slow because of the expanded engagement of minor parties and there were unpredicted preference flows. It took 13 days before the Leader of the Opposition conceded defeat. (more…)

  • GOOD READING AND LISTENING FOR THE WEEKEND …

    Looming in the New Year is debate over the Government’s anti-lobbying legislation, dressed up as a move against foreign influence. Fairfax journalist Peter Martin warns that if the Coalition gets its way, when the next election comes around charities would be prevented doing anything that may be seen as attempting to influence how people vote.  (The Murdoch media, although it is foreign-owned, and the Minerals Council would still be fee to influence how people vote, because they are not charities.) ABC political reporter Anna Henderson comments on the government’s appointment of former Keating-era Labor MP Gary Johns as the new charities commissioner, “a staunch critic of charities that conduct public advocacy work”.

    Peter Martin also warns us not to get too excited about promises of income tax cuts. His basic message is that the Commonwealth budget cannot afford a significant tax cut. Wage rises forecast in recent budgets, which would have allowed for cuts to compensate for bracket creep, haven’t occurred.  Perhaps another reason for fiscal tightness is that many corporations are paying no tax, in data presented by the ABC’s Emily Clark.

    German pilots are refusing to deport asylum seekers – the Independent

    Amazon’s track record may signal a change in Australian industrial relations – TheConversation

    Turnbull’s department head says Tony Abbott damaged the public service.

    Government’s social security cuts seem all toughness and no love – Ross Gittins

    Lesley Russell describes how commercialisation and the greater dominance of private providers has led to lower standards in aged care.

    Ross Gittins writes about voters rejecting the fruits of neoliberalism, privatisation and many other economic reforms.

    In a time of deep political, social and economic uncertainty for everyone (except the ultra-rich), Noam Chomsky and Robert Pollin provide some theoretical and practical guidance for the left. This Truthout interview is an effort to help reimagine a realistic social order in an age when the old order is dying but the new has yet to be born.

  • GRAHAM HAND. No, Gladys, build it and they will not come

    The NSW Government has announced it will knock down and rebuild Allianz Stadium at Moore Park at a cost of $700 million and the Olympic Stadium at Homebush, only 17 years old, at a cost of $1.6 billion. However, there is little ‘business case’ evidence that new stadiums would make a material difference to attendances at football games, although Sports Minister, Stuart Ayres argues, “With better quality facilities, more people will come and attend matches.”   (more…)

  • Why should Israel’s lobby have different standards?

    The government’s plans to tackle  foreign influence in Australian life provide an opportunity for the first time to define the level of Israeli activity designed to influence the making of our foreign policy. George Brandis didn’t plan this. But it is likely to be an outcome.  (more…)

  • TIM COSTELLO. A striking lack of ambition.

    The Turnbull Government’s white paper on Australian foreign policy has raised as many questions as it has provided answers. Much comment has focused on its failure to resolve, or even point to a resolution of, the tension between Australia’s unwavering adherence to US hegemony and the undeniable rise of China as a global and regional power. (more…)

  • ALLAN PATIENCE. It’s time for a citizens’ constitutional convention.

    Unsurprisingly, very few Australians have any interest in their Constitution. It was designed in the closing stages of the 19th century by mostly older white men (no women were involved) for a “horse and buggy” era. It is an awfully dull document, originally an Act of the British parliament, intended to persuade a gaggle of recalcitrant colonies to come together into a federal compact. In contemporary Australia there is no serious educating of citizens about the extent of federal powers, the complexities of federal-state relations, whether the Constitution is truly protective of human rights, and just how adaptive it is to the challenges of the contemporary world. (more…)

  • TONY SMITH. A hope for the future?

    There is plenty to criticise in the current state of Australian politics. It is important that expert commentators continue to point out the shortcomings of the system and the poor quality of those attracted to politics. There are however, occasional reasons for optimism and the inaugural speech of the new Greens Senator for Western Australia is certainly one worth noting. (more…)

  • ROSS GWYTHER. A sledgehammer for a walnut ?

    Unbeknown to most Australians, a court case has been underway in Alice Springs over the past few months with implications far and wide.  Employing a sixty year old law drafted during the height of the anti-communist 1950s in Australia, the Federal Government has called for seven years jail for each member of a small group of people known as the Pine Gap Peace Pilgrims, whose only offence was singing and praying in the grounds of Pine Gap in 2016. (more…)

  • JAMES O’NEILL. The North Korean situation requires a different policy

    It is said that one definition of insanity is to repeat the same process over and over again and expect a different result. That axiom was never truer than when it is applied to United States and Australian policy towards North Korea. (more…)

  • LUKE FRASER. Is Sydney in thrall to an infrastructure cargo cult? (Part 1 of 3)

    This is the first of three articles considering transport infrastructure spending levels, shortcomings in transport governance and strategy and the potential for doing better. (more…)

  • RICHARD BUTLER. North Korea joins the club

    North Korea (DPRK) has made clear that it expects recognition as a nuclear weapon state (NWS). It has now implied, like most existing NWS, that it would follow a policy of “no first use”. US policy continues to be that DPRK nuclear weapon capability must be eliminated, or the DPRK will be. (more…)

  • MARK BEESON: When worlds collide: The unlikely relationship between Australia and China

    The debate about Australia’s relationship with China is characterized by a degree of mutual incomprehension born of difference. Both sides share some of the blame for the current bilateral tensions. (more…)

  • JOHN TULLOH. The potholed U.S. road to Jerusalem

    It was a bizarre move earlier this year when a New York real estate investor, with no experience in politics, diplomacy or foreign affairs, was appointed to broker an Israeli/Palestinian settlement. He would follow in the footsteps of a succession of seasoned diplomatic hagglers who all departed empty handed. Now his task is likely to be more impossible than ever thanks to his father-in-law. (more…)

  • MICHAEL PASCOE. What’s the story behind the Dastyari story?

    What do leaking spooks, a dashed Dastyari and a dubious donor say about our most important trade partner? (more…)

  • ALLAN PATIENCE. The Coalition government: In thrall to the Nationals.

    The National Party receives about 7 % of the vote nation-wide in general elections. This is less than the Greens. Meanwhile over-all support for the Nationals is trending downwards. As a minority rump within the Coalition they nonetheless wield power that is way out of proportion to their representation in parliament. Coalition politics it seems is in thrall to the populist right. (more…)

  • JOHN AUSTEN. The NSW infrastructure mess keeps getting worse

    This is an update on Sydney’s infrastructure puff piece saga. Previous articles in Pearls and Irritations pointed out that the NSW Government led by the Hon. Gladys Berejiklian MP does not understand infrastructure.  The draft 40-year plans for transport and for the Sydney region are a mess, involve kindergarten errors and contradict each other.  It now looks like the wheels are falling off.  The Commonwealth must step in if only for its own sake.  (more…)

  • LAURIE PATTON. Unpopulate or perish – revisiting the Whitlam decentralisation vision in a digital age.

    On the 45th anniversary of the election of the Whitlam Government Laurie Patton reflects on a forward-thinking policy that deserves revisiting for a digitally-enabled world. (more…)

  • MUNGO MacCALLUM. Malcolm Turnbull and John Barilaro.

    When the New South Wales Nationals leader John Barilaro called for Malcolm Turnbull’s resignation last week, it was simple for Turnbull’s federal allies to dismiss it as just another distraction – just another frustrated voice howling into the empty air.   (more…)

  • GOOD READING AND LISTENING FOR THE WEEKEND …

    Australian shareholders should be told of climate risk to profits, says think tank

    Triple J did the right thing: we need a new Australia Day – Henry Reynolds in The Conversation

    Banks warned of ‘regulatory action’ as climate change bites global economy – the Guardian

    Why South Australia must, and will, lead world on renewables – RenewEconomy

    Stephen Hawkings promotes smart drugs – Jon Stewart in Forbes magazine 

    Behrouz Boochani exposed Australia’s evil on Manus. The shame will outlive us all | Richard Flanagan – the Guardian.

    “The cost of living is soaring: look at electricity prices for example.”  That’s a common belief, held by many people struggling to make ends meet, but Ross Gittins reminds us that the source of the struggle is low wage growth, not inflation (The real reason you’re feeling the pinch, Fairfax press 20 Nov).  Low wage growth and low inflation are both attributable, in large part, to intense competition and technological change.

    Marrying across Australia’s Catholic-Protestant divide in the old days – the Conversation

    South Australia’s Royal Commission into water theft may be just the tip of iceberg for the Murray Darling Basin – Jamie Pittock in the Conversation.

  • BRUCE DUNCAN. Did Pope Francis succeed in Myanmar?

    Myanmar’s neighbours were watching closely the Pope’s visit, worried that the shocking treatment of the Rohingya Muslims could inflame inter-religious conflicts throughout the region. Francis has intervened personally to promote deeper mutual understanding among the major religions, urging them to draw from their traditions to protect those in distress and promote social inclusion and universal human values. (more…)

  • JERRY ROBERTS Parliamentary reform needs external drive

    Privatisation and corporatisation of government services such as Australia Post have reduced the power and influence of the Parliament and made it less relevant to our daily lives. Parliamentary reform is important but needs to be seen as part of a bigger picture – much bigger. (more…)

  • BRUCE WEARNE A Suggestion to the Ruddock Committee

    The discussion of Freedom of Religion in relation to proposed changes to the Marriage Act should not avoid analysis of how the current Act refers to a wedding ceremony’s “monitum”. The Marriage Act decrees that the “Monitum” must be announced when a marriage is conducted by one authorised to do so. But how now will a new “monitum” function under the proposed changes to the Act? How will the Act’s view of the wedding ceremony be configured?   (more…)

  • DAVID WATTERS AND COLLEAGUES. An open letter to the Australian Parliament regarding the health of asylum seekers and refugees on Manus Island

    (The following letter appeared in the MJA Insight on 27 November 2017)

    WE are senior Australian clinicians who write in our individual capacity to express our concerns about the ongoing health and well-being of the former detainees still based on Manus Island and now in alternative accommodation. They, like all human beings, have a universal right – enshrined in the United Nations charter – to health and well-being. Their political and citizenship status should not affect this right. All politicians regardless of their political party should respect the human right to health and themselves be strong advocates of “health for all” without discrimination. (more…)

  • MIKE WALLER. The Royal Commission we really need – into Australia’s public administration.

     As Terry Moran has recently pointed out, our system of public administration is in serious trouble.  The last fundamental look at Australian federal public administration was some forty years ago – the Coombs Royal Commission.  We urgently need a successor to Coombs’ forensic and thoughtful approach, but this time addressing the necessary reforms of all levels of government. (more…)

  • TERRY MORAN. Back in the game. Part 2 of 2.

    Active and effective government

    I want to highlight two messages from the attitudes research that I referred to in Part 1.  First, the health of our democracy can’t be divorced from the health of our public institutions and our public sector.  Second, getting back in the game means investing in an Australian Public Service (and a Victorian Public Service) that can think for itself, not smothering it with a dominant microeconomic paradigm that no longer works and the community no longer supports.   (more…)

  • Myanmar Is Not a Simple Morality Tale

    In this article published in the New York Times on November 25, 2017, Roger Cohen writes about the dilemma of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.  He comments ‘The West made a saint of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. The Rohingya crisis revealed a politician.’  
    (more…)

  • TERRY MORAN ‘Back in the Game’ Part 1 of 2

    The policy pendulum is swinging away from a consensus on the primacy of light touch regulation of markets, the unexamined benefits of outsourced service delivery, a general preference for smaller government, and a willing ignorance of public sector values and culture because they’re not always compatible with efficiency as viewed by Treasuries. 

    Replacing this consensus is an increasing acceptance of a larger role for government, including involvement in service delivery, more effective regulation and bolder policy initiatives.   (more…)

  • ELIZABETH EVATT. Why not protect all our rights and freedoms?

    The proposal to legislate for freedom of thought ,conscience and religion, as provided in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights is a half measure which would leave other rights and freedoms without equivalent protection. And it may not produce the result which is aimed at. (more…)

  • IAN DUNLOP. Climate & Energy – Appeasement Does Not Work

    The current chaos around climate and energy policy brings to mind George Santayana’s caution that: “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it”. That is exactly what we are witnessing, albeit with far more profound implications even than the advent of the Second World War.   (more…)