Blog

  • A whitewash rather than a white paper on how we go to war

    The ‘organising principle’ of the 2017 foreign policy White Paper is the importance of and commitment to a rules-based order. At the heart of that order lies the United Nations and “Australia is a principled and pragmatic member of the United Nations, contributing to its vital security, environmental and humanitarian endeavours” (p. 81). In one important respect,how we go to war,it is a whitewash rather than a white paper. (more…)

  • MUNGO MACCALLUM. Tax cuts, religious freedom and Turnbull’s other distractions

    A vague and uncosted promise of tax cuts and a debate on religious freedom are Turnbull’s tactics to push serious policy issues off the Parliamentary agenda, and to distract public attention from the Coalition’s troubles. (more…)

  • IAN MCAULEY. Queensland election: a policy challenge for the Coalition

    The Queensland election has been a disaster for the Liberal-National Party. There is a risk that the Coalition will misinterpret the result and become even more alienated from the Australian electorate. (more…)

  • TIM LINDSEY. Will Indonesia’s fugitive Speaker escape again? The elite’s war on the Anti-Corruption Commission continues.

     Indonesians have been riveted for the last two weeks by a bizarre series of events that finally led to the arrest late last week of Setya Novanto, the speaker of the DPR, Indonesia’s national legislature.   (more…)

  • MACK WILLIAMS. 2017 Foreign Policy White Paper : An urgent case for genuine change management !

    The White Paper provides a long overdue but commendable assessment of the extensive challenges and opportunities for Australian foreign policy. It should have formed the basis for considered parliamentary debate. Unfortunately, while acknowledging for the first time the extent and pace of change, it offers few new or fresh ideas on how it should be managed and is preoccupied with maintaining what it can of the status quo. (more…)

  • MUNGO MACCALLUM. Bishop’s credibility leaking away.

    The government of Malcolm Turnbull has now transcended mere dysfunction – it has lapsed into anarchy, total chaos. (more…)

  • SUSAN RYAN. A roof over their heads.

    The Annual Report for 2016 of the Women’s Housing Company demonstrates solutions to the terrible and growing situation of older women facing homelessness. These solutions however continue to elude policy makers, the media and business, whose failures to recognise the size of the problem and its costs to the public purse inflict great damage on the human rights of poorer older women. (more…)

  • ALLAN PATIENCE. The complacency of the 2017 Foreign Policy White Paper.

    The 2017 White Paper displays, yet again, Australia’s foreign policy complacency, its misplaced middle power imagining, and its awkward partnering in its region. It is a failure as a strategic map for advancing Australia’s security and prosperity in the “Indo-Pacific” region and the world. (more…)

  • BOB CARR. Foreign Policy White Paper: Faulty roadmap in a GPS world.

    While the Australian government’s Foreign Policy White Paper was at the printers, it was being overtaken by events. (more…)

  • FRANCESCA BEDDIE. The way ahead for VET

    The Productivity Commission’s five-year review, Shifting the Dial, recommends reforms in vocational education and training (VET). These are based on ‘the key premise…that skills formation is one of the central pillars for productivity improvement, even if its benefits are not immediately realised’. That caveat is important: neither skills acquisition nor other knowledge gains are easily quantified, nor are their effects on individuals straightforward. Nevertheless, as the latest Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show, more and more Australians are seeking post-school qualifications. Most do so because they want a job and decent income. Some are mesmerised by learning and marvel at the wonder of human endeavour and the natural world. They are not thinking about productivity statistics yet may turn out to be vital assets in guarding our civilisation. (more…)

  • RICHARD KINGSFORD. Policy holes drain the life out of Murray-Darling rivers.

    We are often told by some politicians and irrigation lobbyists not to worry about our rivers – Australia is a land of droughts and flooding rains – and ever it was thus. After all, Murray-Darling rivers surely fixed themselves when the 2010 and 2011 floods broke the seven year Millennium Drought. This tired old talking point is wrong – unequivocally demonstrated by reductions in river flows and thousands of hectares of dead river red gums. Critics of environmental flows for rivers argue that the so-called poor state of the rivers is nothing more than a figment of the imagination of the disconnected environmental fringe, mostly in our cities and scientists intent on growing their empires. (more…)

  • GOOD READING AND LISTENING FOR THE WEEKEND …

     

    The only argument about housing prices seems to be whether they will crash or fall slowly.  Paul Keating warns of a possible “Minsky moment” – a sudden and spectacular crash. A paper published by Ben Phillips and Cukkoo Joseph of ANU, going into regional detail, finds that there is already an oversupply in some inner-city regions, but suggests that oversupply in itself is unlikely to reduce prices to any significant extent in the short term. Core Logic reports that auction clearance rates in Sydney and Melbourne have been on a noticeable downward trend over the last twelve months.

    Wayne Byrnes, Chairman of The Australian Prudential Regulatory Authority has given a speech warning: “The broader environment of high and rising leverage, encouraged by historically low interest rates, requires ongoing prudence. It is easy to run up debt, but far harder to pay it back down when circumstances change”.  Those seeking a summary of Byrnes’ speech will find one by Clancy Yates, writing in the Fairfax Press.

    Wage growth, or the lack of it, is in the news. The ABC has three related but separate stories: Carrington Clarke “Cost cutting hurting workers and the economy” summarising a speech by Reserve Bank Governor Philip Lowe; Stephen Letts and Michael Janda “Wage growth mired near record lows”, citing the ABS Wage Price Index; and Michael Janda “Australian workers gift $130b to employers through unpaid overtime”, based on work by Jim Stanford of the Australia Institute’s Centre for Future Work.

    Ross Gittins points out that, as a source of economic advice, Treasury’s power has been waning, with more influence coming from the Productivity Commission and the Reserve Bank, institutions more in touch with the real world. Labor, if elected, would boost the influence of the Parliamentary Budget Office.

    A Washington Post-Kaiser Family Foundation poll has found that those identifying themselves as “Christians” are far more likely than “non-Christians”  to blame poverty on individual failings rather than people’s circumstances: “46 percent of all Christians said that a lack of effort is generally to blame for a person’s poverty, compared with 29 percent of all non-Christians”.  Among “white evangelicals” 53 percent blamed the individual.

    In defiance of media predictions that Labor would retain the seat of Northcote in a Victorian state by-election, the Greens had a convincing victory. With 45 per cent of the primary vote, against 35 per cent for Labor, they easily cruised through on preferences. The Liberals did not contest the election in a metropolitan seat that Labor has held for aeons,  but even though those who were disinclined to Labor or Green had the choice of another 10 candidates, they secured only 20 per cent of the vote between them. (Figures from William Bowe’s Poll Bludger.)

    Richard Butler wrote in this blog that nuclear war is becoming ‘thinkable ,again’. This article shows a US Marines F-35 squadron is training to fight through nuclear war against North Korea – Business Insider.

    Twelve Australians of the Year write an open letter to the PM on Manus Island.

    Infographics in The Conversation show exactly what Adani’s Carmichael mine means for Queensland.

    The owner of the Carmichael project can’t walk away from mine without descending further into distress, says an energy expert in The Guardian.

    With the mining boom spent, the big infrastructure spend on the gas industry gone, and the east coast housing boom in its final phase, it seems there’s little ammo in the locker left to help fire up a wages lift any time soon – but there’s a silver lining, writes Ian Verrender. Read the full story

    Richard Denniss explains that the coalition is unpopular because it has unpopular policies (Canberra Times)

    Tim Hollo explains that Australia’s ageing constitution is past its ‘best-by’ date (Canberra Times)

     

     

  • JIM COOMBS. Is “Parliamentary Reform” needed?

    When we contemplate the hopelessness of our national (and state) politics now, we are tempted, like John Menadue, to think that tinkering with the machine will turn a clapped out jalopy into a Roller. It is more likely the quality of the driver that is the problem. (more…)

  • JOHN MENADUE. 2017 Foreign Policy White Paper.

    Yesterday, the government released the 2017 Foreign Policy White Paper.

      A group associated with Pearls & Irritations made a submission in the preparation of the White Paper:  Submission on foreign policy white paper – filling the void.

    The media release concerning the White Paper follows.  That media release also carries a link to the full White Paper.

    Next week Pearls and Irritations will be reviewing and commenting on the White Paper

    (more…)

  • EVA COX. Unhealthy Tribalism

    The marriage equality survey has re-enforced the tribal type divides that now seem increasingly endemic in our socially defined political differences. Like most Western democratic nations, we are finding that the traditional views about voters as predictable blocs of left and right or class based voting groups are becoming increasingly less relevant. The growth of factions and fraction are displacing the comfortable labelling of party loyalists or simple categories. To add to the confusion, categories such as radical and conservative have also become less useful to define what people are thinking. (more…)

  • BRUCE DUNCAN. Francis’s World Day of the Poor. ‘The poor are our passports to paradise’.

    Even atheists, agnostics and humanists, as well as people of the great religious traditions, would likely welcome Pope Francis instituting a new World Day of the Poor. While a shallow and at times vulgar commercialism trivialises the profound religious meaning of Christmas, the World Day of the Poor highlights our God-given responsibility for all in distress. (more…)

  • GREG BAILEY. On the Importance and the Difficulty of Renewing Australian Democracy

    John Menadue has offered a series of nine excellent practical proposals as to how the current two party system – which has virtually assumed monopoly status as a duopoly–might be converted into a multi-party system. This would seemingly reflect the real concerns of Australian voters whose voting patterns – by the increasing percentage of votes going to minor parties – show increasing support for a multiparty system. But can the very useful suggestion of “a professional and independent review of our parliament and the democratic renewal” really come to fruition and what would be needed to bring it into operation? (more…)

  • IAN MACPHEE. A deeper view of the Rohingya crisis than media provide.

    Since writing my blog on 13 October in defence of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi (whom I will now only term Daw Suu) external media has continued its criticism of her for not condemning the military for its brutal attacks on Rohingya people in Rakhine state on the border of Bangladesh. As I stressed then, I have no doubt that Daw Suu would be as appalled as most people about the rapid military action of which she would have had no knowledge until it occurred. But, had she condemned the brutality she would have risked being displaced by the military and unable to achieve anything for the rest of Myanmar.   (more…)

  • ALISON BROINOWSKI. If you want to know the truth

    WikiLeaks continues to get up the nose of the media and security establishment. They will use a newly revealed proposal to make Assange Ambassador to Washington to make things worse for him. (more…)

  • MICHAEL KELLY. What brings a Jesuit Pope to Asia?

    One of the biggest influences on Pope Francis remains relatively unexplored – Pedro Arrupe, the Superior General of the Jesuits (1965-83) who appointed Jorge Bergoglio Provincial of the Jesuits in Argentina (1973-79) at the tender age of 36. (more…)

  • CHRIS BONNOR. Wealthy parents flock to public schools

    The results of the 2016 census are continuing to roll out. This time it is the turn of school education to grab the headlines, most recently with Fairfax telling us that wealthy families are turning away from elite private schools. (more…)

  • STEPHEN LONG. The Adani lobbyist and Labor insider who smoothed the way for the mega mine

    Adani’s lobbyists resigned recently after a job well done.

    Key points:

    • Lobbyists made 33 contacts with Queensland politicians or their staff for Adani
    • 60 per cent of meetings the Queensland Premier held with lobbyists were for Adani
    • Adani lobbyist played key role in Labor’s 2016 federal election campaign

    (more…)

  • RICHARD BUTLER. Making the use of nuclear weapons thinkable – again?

    The Trump  Administration is preparing a new Nuclear Posture Review, (NPR) to be completed by early 2018. The instruction under which it is proceeding is to make US nuclear weapons more useable, in a variety of situations. It is being preceded by a massive program of new nuclear weapons development. Russia is also embarked on a similar program of expansion of its nuclear weapons capability. It seems that these weapons are being designed to be used more widely, not simply to serve as a deterrent force. (more…)

  • JAMES O’NEILL. The Syrian Denouement nears despite Australia’s unwanted and illegal presence

    The Australian government is a regular citer of what it calls the “rules based international order.” When it calls on other countries to desist from behaviour of which it disapproves.  The recitation is frequently applied to the South China Sea where the Australian government disapproves of what it calls “Chinese assertiveness” in the region. (more…)

  • PETER RODGERS. Mohammad bin Salman – Saudi Arabia’s reformer or wrecker?

    Perhaps as a child Mohammad bin Salman watched too much Superman.  Now, as Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince, he’s dashing hither and thither, ostensibly remaking the royal family, the country and the region. In his wake there’s profound confusion, national austerity mixed with personal profligacy, imprisoned billionaires, bruised egos, civil war, fractured alliances, recovered loot and many crossed fingers. Will MbS (as he is invariably dubbed) end the Kingdom’s addiction to oil and change its lazy economic ways? Will he force Iran and its backers to pull their heads in, acknowledge Saudi suzerainty and the joy of regional peace and Trumpism? Will he find a cure for the pathogen infecting Saudi Islam and drag his kingdom in the 21st century? Or will his dictatorial and impetuous ways blow up the House of Saud, destroying enemies and friends alike?   (more…)

  • KIM WINGEREI. Book Review of “Reboot – A Democracy Makeover to Empower Australia’s Voters” – by Richard Walsh

    The respect for our politicians is at an all-time low. Voters of all ages, but especially the young, are turning away from the political discourse in disgust; The recent citizenship debacle and the same sex marriage plebiscite that wasn’t, have been new low points in a decade high on political drama, low on any kind of meaningful reform. In his book – Reboot – A Democracy Makeover to Empower Australia’s Voters (Melbourne University Press – 2017), Richard Walsh is tackling the core issues head on with some novel ideas on how we, the voters, may get the elected representatives that we deserve, rather than the party delegates who serve us so poorly today. (more…)

  • DUNCAN GRAHAM. Wanted: The real refugee story

    There should be no asylum seekers in offshore camps funded by Australia.  They’re getting food, healthcare and accommodation – even money. But the prolonged wait is inhumane and damaging.  Impractical solutions and unbalanced reporting are compounding the problem. (more…)

  • GILES PARKINSON. LNP, One Nation would force Queensland energy prices up; Greens, ALP down

    A new analysis of the energy policies presented by the major and smaller parties contesting the Queensland state election shows that the Greens would deliver the biggest electricity savings, Labor would also push prices down, while One Nation and the LNP policies would force prices to rise.

    (more…)

  • MUNGO MacCALLUM. What silent majority?

    The best thing about the same sex marriage survey (apart, of course, from the entirely predictable numbers) is that it finally and conclusively disproves the myth of the silent majority – the conservative fantasy that somehow, somewhere, there is a great mass of Australians who are against all progressive change but have never actually said so.  (more…)

  • GREG WOOD. The Australian Dream: Many Belts Many Roads.

    The ALP has indicated that, if elected, it will consider positively China’s so called One Belt One Road initiative. The ambition of BRI is vast. It would reshape global trade, transport and logistics in a China-centric way to meet that country’s requirements, contribute to it becoming the world’s pre-eminent economy and, ultimately, its dominant power. It fits with President Xi’s articulation of the Chinese Dream, the national rejuvenation of China as the Middle Kingdom, the communist party front and centre of that objective. Is Labor on the right path? If the Chinese have a dream do we need an Australian Dream? (more…)