Gregory Clark

Remember the Vietnam War? The barbarism there cannot be compared with what we see almost daily in Gaza. But just looking on impotently will not solve the problem.

(more…)

Vladimir Putin rarely uses English in his speeches. So if in his speech to the recent BRICS meeting in Kazan he insisted the reason for Russia’s 2022 attack on Ukraine was that he was duped (he pronounced it ‘dooped’) by Germany and France in the 2014-5 Minsk Accords then he probably meant it. (more…)

Japan’s new prime minister, Ishiba Shigeru, has called for an Asian NATO. But salivating hawks should restrain the glee. (more…)

What a difference a day (or a week) makes. What a difference the mere translation of a word makes. (more…)

With Japan’s former prime minister, Shinzo Abe, assassinated, Japan’s current prime minister, Fumio Kishida, has been saying he wants direct talks with North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong Un -a reversal of Abe’s position. (more…)

The recent Statement from former Australian Foreign Ministers Gareth Evans and Bob Carr calling for Australia to play a role in seeking detente between the US and China in Asia is worthy.  But is it realistic?

It tells us that the Australia-Japan initiated International Commission on Nuclear Non- Proliferation and Disarmament of 2009, is a model of creative, middle power diplomacy.

But in the name of protecting its own security Tokyo rejects any disarmament proposal that hints of sacrificing absolute US nuclear security. How is that supposed to promote detente in Asia?

A resolution of the North Korea problem must be a key to any such detente.  But Tokyo was directly responsible for sabotaging the 2002 Pyongyang Declaration that would have seen North Korea make its first move to nuclear disarmament and to joining in North Asia diplomacy.

The sabotage was largely the handiwork of former (now deceased) Japanese prime minister, Shinzo Abe, assisted by fanatical anti-Pyongyang elements who say North Korea is hiding and using people abducted secretly from Japan more than 50 years ago. Some insist the number of abductees could be close to eight hundred.

This is totally unsubstantiated ‘fairies in the attic’ fantasy. Yet the abductee problem was recently voiced again by Japan’s prime minister Fumio Kishida as reason to keep pressure on Pyongyang.

How can we have detente in Asia if Tokyo’s unrepentant foreign policy fanatics continue to receive encouragement at the highest levels?

That Declaration was largely the work of a senior, dedicated Japanese Foreign Ministry official, Hitoshi Tanaka, and the then North Korean leader, Kim Jong Il.  How can Asia move to detente when the painstaking work of detente-minded individuals can be so easily discarded?

The Evans-Carr detente statement calls for a freezing of the Taiwan Straits status-quo. But we know this is something Beijing cannot accept.  Nor, one assumes, can Australia or the US, since both accepted in the seventies Beijing’s treaty-based claims to Taiwan and both insist they continue to abide by a rules-based international order.

How can there be any detente in Asia if major powers can be allowed to say one thing one day and something different the next, simply as a matter of convenience?

The Statement calls for both sides to ‘desist from demands for absolute primacy’.  But at last call Beijing was not seeking any absolute primacy. It was the US with its claims to exceptionalism.

The overall tone of the Statement is cautious, anxiously seeking the middle of the road – similar to what we used to hear during the Vietnam War, with both sides unrealistically called to accept the status quo. Detente in Asia demands some attempt to find justice. Would it be expected to endorse repression by Myanmar generals, for example.

The Statement mentions Henry Kissinger and the former Soviet leader, Leonid Brezhnev, as examples of detente seekers. Kissinger deserves credit for his 1971 move to open the door to China. But the latter was the author of the Brezhnev Doctrine justifying Soviet 1968 intervention to crush Czechoslovakia’s liberalisation.

Nikita Khrushchev was a much better Soviet example. His efforts at detente could have ended the Cold War. But they were shot down by US hawks. And he was overthrown in 1964 by Leonid Brezhnev.

Slovakia is the poor relation created when the former Czechoslovakia divided in 1993 into the Czech and Slovak Republics. The Czech Republic has hewn closely to EU and NATO policies over Ukraine. But despite NATO membership the Slovak Republic has decided to halt military aid to Ukraine. And its prime minister, Robert Fico, has now come out with a strong pro-Russian statement over the Ukraine conflict. (more…)

Between years 2000 and 2018 the North Korea and South Korea governments issued three joint declarations all promising South Korean economic aid to North Korea and North Korean moves to denuclearisation. (more…)

Where fear of China is involved there is no conscience for the mistakes of the past. Nor can we expect any sensibility in the plans for the future. (more…)

The latest Japanese political scandal involving at least four top government ministers and numerous junior officials is widely seen as a fatal blow to the prime minister Fumio Kishida already dogged by a weak image and record low popularity polls. (more…)